JEE Advance - Physics (2018 - Paper 1 Offline - No. 4)

Two infinitely long straight wires lie in the $$xy$$-plane along the lines $$x = \pm R.$$ The wire located at $$x = + R$$ carries a constant current $${I_1}$$ and the wire located at $$x=-R$$ carries a constant current $${I_2}.$$ A circular loop of radius $$R$$ is suspended with its center at $$\left( {0,0,\sqrt 3 R} \right)$$ and in a plane parallel to the $$xy$$-plane. This loop carries a constant current $$I$$ in the clockwise direction as seen from above the loop. The current in the wire is taken to be positive if it is in the $$ + \widehat j$$ direction. which of the following statements regarding the magnetic field $$\overrightarrow B $$ is (are) true?
If $${I_1} = {I_2},$$ then $$\overrightarrow B $$ cannot be equal to zero at the origin $$(0,0,0)$$
If $${I_1} > 0$$ and $${I_2} < 0,$$ then $$\overrightarrow B $$ can be equal to zero at the origin $$(0,0,0)$$
If $${I_1} < 0$$ and $${I_2} > 0,$$ then $$\overrightarrow B $$ can be equal to zero at the origin $$(0,0,0)$$
If $${I_1} = {I_2},$$ then the $$z$$-component of the magnetic field at the center of the loop is $$\left( { - {{{\mu _0}I} \over {2R}}} \right)$$

Explanation

JEE Advanced 2018 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Magnetism Question 46 English Explanation 1

The magnetic field at the origin O (0, 0, 0) due to the infinitely long straight wire located at x = +R is

$${\overrightarrow B _1}(O) = {{{\mu _0}{i_1}} \over {2\pi R}}\widehat k$$

and due to the infinitely long straight wire located at x = $$-$$R is

$${\overrightarrow B _2}(O) = {{{\mu _0}{i_2}} \over {2\pi R}}( - \widehat k)$$.

The magnetic field at O due to the circular loop is

$${\overrightarrow B _3}(O) = {{{\mu _0}i{R^2}} \over {2{{({R^2} + {{(\sqrt 3 R)}^2})}^{3/2}}}}( - \widehat k) = {{{\mu _0}i} \over {16R}}( - \widehat k)$$.

The resultant magnetic field at the origin (0, 0, 0) is

$${\overrightarrow B _3}(O) = {\overrightarrow B _1}(O) + {\overrightarrow B _2}(O) + {\overrightarrow B _3}(O)$$

$$ = {{{\mu _0}} \over {16\pi R}}(8({i_1} - {i_2}) - \pi i)\widehat k$$.

Thus, if i1 = i2 then $${\overrightarrow B _1}(O) = - {\overrightarrow B _2}(O)$$ and $${\overrightarrow B _1}(O) = {\overrightarrow B _3}(O) \ne \overrightarrow 0 $$.

If i1 > 0 and i2 < 0 then both $${\overrightarrow B _1}(O)$$ and $${\overrightarrow B _2}(O)$$ are along $$\widehat k$$ but $${\overrightarrow B _3}(O)$$ is along $$-$$$$\widehat k$$. Thus, resultant field $$\overrightarrow B (O)$$ can be zero.

If i1 < 0 and i2 > 0 then $${\overrightarrow B _1}(O)$$, $${\overrightarrow B _2}(O)$$ and $${\overrightarrow B _3}(O)$$ are all along $$-$$$$\widehat k$$. Thus, resultant field $$\overrightarrow B (O)$$ cannot be zero. We encourage you to relate these results with the feasible solutions of 8(i1 $$-$$ i2) $$-$$ $$\pi$$i = 0 for i > 0.

Now, let us find the magnetic field at the centre of the loop i.e., point C in the figure.

JEE Advanced 2018 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Magnetism Question 46 English Explanation 2

The magnetic field $$\overrightarrow B_1$$ at the point C due to the infinitely long straight wire located x = +R is perpendicular to the line AC (see figure). It lies in the x-z plane and makes an angle 30$$^\circ$$ with the x axis. Resolve $$\overrightarrow B_1$$ along the x and z directions to get

$${{\vec B}_1}(C) = {{{\mu _0}{i_1}} \over {2\pi (2R)}}(\cos 30^\circ \widehat i + \sin 30^\circ \widehat k)$$.

Similarly, the magnetic field at C due to the infinitely long straight wire located at x = $$-$$R is

$${{\vec B}_2}(C) = {{{\mu _0}{i_2}} \over {2\pi (2R)}}(\cos 30^\circ \widehat i - \sin 30^\circ \widehat k)$$.

The magnetic field at C due to the circular loop is

$${{\vec B}_3}(C) = {{{\mu _0}i} \over {(2R)}}( - \widehat k)$$.

The resultant magnetic field at C is

$${{\vec B}_1}(C) = {{\vec B}_1}(C) + {{\vec B}_2}(C) + {{\vec B}_3}(C) = {{{\mu _0}} \over {8\pi R}}\left( {\sqrt 3 ({i_1} + {i_2})\widehat i + ({i_1} - {i_2} - 4\pi i)\widehat k} \right)$$.

If i1 = i2 then magnitudes of $${{\vec B}_1}(C)$$ and $${{\vec B}_2}(C)$$ are equal and their z-components are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction. Thus, z-component of the magnetic field at C is due to the circular loop only and its value is $$\left( { - {{{\mu _0}i} \over {2R}}} \right)$$.

Comments (0)

Advertisement